How to Choose the Right Tax Professional: A Guide for US Small Business Owners
4 min read
24 February 2025

Take outs:

  • Ensure the tax professional has a valid Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN) and is qualified to handle your business's tax needs. The IRS offers resources like the Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers to help you identify qualified professionals.

  • Be cautious of tax preparers who exhibit unethical behavior, such as not signing the return, offering large refunds, or charging fees based on the refund amount. Always confirm the preparer’s credentials and their legitimacy.

  •  Choose a tax professional who offers year-round support, not just during tax season. This ensures they can address any ongoing concerns and provide continuous guidance for your business. 

  • Trustworthy professionals will discuss fees upfront and base them on the complexity of your tax return, not on the size of your refund. Always make sure you are clear on fees before committing to services.

How to Choose the Right Tax Professional: A Guide for US Small Business Owners

As tax season approaches, it’s crucial for small business owners to ensure they are working with a trustworthy tax professional. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) recently reminded taxpayers about the importance of selecting the right tax preparer, not only to ensure their taxes are filed correctly but also to protect against fraud and identity theft. While many tax professionals provide excellent service, there are some bad actors who may put your personal and financial information at risk.

At Kelly+Partners, we pride ourselves on delivering high-quality tax services tailored to small business owners. Our team of experienced professionals is here to guide you through the tax filing process with integrity, expertise, and year-round support.

Here are some essential tips to help you choose the right tax professional, avoid scams, and ensure a smooth tax filing process for your business:

Use IRS Resources to Find a Qualified Professional

The IRS provides valuable tools and resources to help taxpayers make informed decisions. You can use the Directory of Federal Tax Return Preparers with Credentials and Select Qualifications to find a tax professional who meets high standards. The IRS also offers a dedicated page on its website for Choosing a Tax Professional, which provides guidance on how to avoid unethical preparers and outlines the different types of tax return preparers available.

For small business owners, it’s important to select a preparer who understands your unique needs and business structure.

Be Aware of Red Flags

Recognizing red flags can help you avoid falling victim to fraud. For instance, “ghost” preparers are a significant concern. These are individuals who won’t sign the tax return as the paid preparer and may ask you to sign and file the return yourself. This is a huge red flag and may signal fraudulent activity. Always ensure your tax preparer signs the return and includes their Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN).

Other red flags include tax preparers who promise large refunds or charge fees based on the refund amount.

Ensure Proper Credentials

Tax preparers are required by law to have a valid Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN) if they’re paid to prepare federal tax returns. Make sure that your tax preparer has a valid PTIN. This ensures that the person you’re working with is legitimate and has met the necessary IRS requirements.

Choose a Tax Preparer Who’s Available Year-Round

Tax-related questions can arise at any time, not just during tax season. It's important to work with a tax preparer who is available year-round for questions or follow-up concerns. This will help ensure that any issues related to your tax return can be addressed promptly.

At Kelly+Partners, we don’t just disappear after tax season. Our team is available year-round to assist with tax planning, audits, and ongoing business advisory services.

Discuss Fees Upfront

Avoid tax preparers who base their fees on a percentage of your refund or ask to deposit your refund into their own bank account. Trustworthy professionals will discuss their fees upfront, and they should be based on the complexity of your tax return, not the refund amount. Make sure you’re comfortable with the fees before agreeing to their services.

Kelly+Partners believes in full transparency. We outline our fees clearly and work with you to ensure our services provide value to your business.

Work with IRS Authorized E-File Providers

Filing electronically with an IRS-authorized e-file provider can streamline the tax filing process and help ensure faster refunds, typically within 21 days. Many IRS-approved e-file providers offer small business owners efficient and secure ways to submit their tax returns.

Our office is an IRS-authorized e-file provider, ensuring that your tax return is processed quickly and securely.

Provide Complete and Accurate Documentation

A reputable tax professional will request all the necessary documentation, including receipts, income details, and relevant tax credits. Ensure you provide complete records for accurate filing. Never let a preparer file a return using a pay stub instead of your Form W-2, as this violates IRS e-file rules.

At Kelly+Partners, we take accuracy seriously. We guide our clients through the documentation process, ensuring compliance while identifying potential tax-saving opportunities.

Never Sign a Blank or Incomplete Return

As a taxpayer, you are ultimately responsible for the accuracy of your tax return, even if someone else prepares it. Never sign a blank or incomplete return. Review your tax return carefully before signing it and ask questions if something doesn’t make sense or looks inaccurate. Make sure that your refund is directed to your account and not to the preparer’s.

Check the Better Business Bureau (BBB)

Before hiring a tax preparer, check their history and reputation with the Better Business Bureau (BBB). The BBB can provide insight into whether the preparer has had any disciplinary actions or complaints. For additional peace of mind, verify the preparer’s license status and certification through relevant state boards.

For small business owners, choosing the right tax professional is a critical step to ensuring compliance and avoiding fraud. By following these tips—such as verifying credentials, watching out for red flags, and asking the right questions—you can protect yourself and your business from potential tax-related issues.

At Kelly+Partners, we take pride in delivering expert tax and advisory services to small business owners. Whether you need tax preparation, bookkeeping, or strategic financial guidance, our team is here to support you every step of the way.

By making an informed decision and working with a trusted professional like Kelly+Partners, you’ll not only avoid scams but also set yourself up for a smooth and efficient tax season.